CANADIAN ASSOCIATION OF RETIRED TEACHERS
    ASSOCIATION CANADIENNE DES ENSEIGNANTES ET DES ENSEIGNANTS RETRAITÉS


Home |

Executive  | Members  | Committees  | Policy  | Links
    
    
WHAT'S NEW


     ARTICLES
    
     NEWSLETTER

     MEETINGS

     AGM REPORT

     HISTORY

     PHOTO

     BIENVENUE

     SEARCH


  ARTICLES

INDEX

Articles:
     Pension Splitting

Briefs:
     CNSO: Submission to the Special Senate Committee on Aging - 2nd Interim Report
June 2, 2008
     ACER-CART Brief: To Standing Committee on Finance, October 6, 2005


Media Releases:
     October 6, 2005 - Presentation to federal pre-budget consultation hearing
    
October 14, 2005 - Support for BC Teachers' Federation in provincial bargaining

     June 6, 2008 - Elder Abuse Awareness Day

Surveys:
     Seniors Online Canada Survey
     Health Care Survey
     Seniors' Priorities Survey
     Long Term Care Survey

Other:
Manitoba Debate on a Government Bill on Teacher Pensions
- Hansard record, July 21, 2008.
Cost of Living Adjustment - by Owen Corcoran, BCRTA Past President
Some Major Features of Canadian Teacher Retirement Plans 2007-08submitted by Vaughn Wadelius, ACER-CART Vice President
Example Letter to Members of Parliament on Pension Splitting
Uniform Improvements Recommended for Enduring Powers of Attorney in the Four Western Provinces
 


COST OF LIVING ADJUSTMENT

by Owen Corcoran, BCRTA Past President

This article first appeared in the BCRTA Spring 2005 edition of Postscript and is published here with the permission of Owen Cocoran.


Great news! You are to receive a 1.8% cola [Cost-of-Living Adjustment] to your pension this year.

If you are fortunate enough to receive a $45,000.00 p.a. stipend this works out to an increase of $810.00 annually, before tax - and any clawback on your Old Age Pension and escalation in your Pharmacare deductible.

Don’t get me wrong! I consider the 1.8% cola a reasonable increase, especially when one considers what our working partners - the teachers and administrators in our public schools- will receive.

But, as you sit huddled over your one bar electric heater, wondering if you should remove your gloves so you can grip your pencil more tightly and actually press the keys of your calculator while you plan how to allocate the cola amount, consider this.

Currently a federal commission is recommending that judicial salaries be raised by 10% this year, plus additional cost of living increases in each of the next three years. Under reforms passed by Parliament in 2001, the salary of federal politicians is tied to that of the judiciary, meaning that the foregoing raises will go to MP’s and senators as well. This move could top 16% over the next four years if one incorporates the annual and automatic cost of living increases.

No! No! Don’t ask me about the Governor General’s budget, the $43,448.00 rose garden and the $5.3 million junket to Russia, Finland and Iceland. Her second Northern Tour has been put on hold by the feds. Surely she has given enough!

Some facts:

1. MP’s are currently paid $140,000.00 per year. This places them in the top 3% of Canadian Income earners.

2. Three years ago, federal politicians voted themselves a 20% raise [the Prime Minister’s raise was 42%], Since then, those salaries have increased by another 7.3% - a total 28.5% increase since 2000. How does your cola increase look now?

3. The recommended 10% increase would jump basic MP salaries to $155,100 this year. And it’s retroactive to April 2004. How does your cola increase look now?

4. The annual cost-of-living additions will see the basic salary rise to $165,000.00 by 2007. A 16.7% boost over four years. How does your cola increase look now?

5. My Grade 9 granddaughter did the math for me as the amounts and the percentages were befuddling. Her calculation - a 50% increase in MP basic salaries since 2000. How does your cola increase look now?

If only this remuneration were reflected in the wisdom and practicality of the laws and decisions which the recipients produce, the universal health care system they control etc. Perhaps then my jaundiced eye would uncloud, my cola would look much more reasonable, and I would view the recipients as models of Plato’s Philosopher King.

If only!!!

BACK TO TOP
 


SOME MAJOR FEATURES OF CANADIAN TEACHER RETIREMENT PLANS 2007-08

The information for the following is based on information supplied by CTF and revised by
Vaughn Wadelius, Vice President of ACER-CART.

A. Benefit Levels Across the Provinces

Prov.

Minimum Service for Pension

Maximum Service Credited

Retirement w/o Reduction Earliest age + (Age & Service Combo)

Earliest Retirement (reduced benefit)

Re-employment as Teacher without penalty

BC

2 years

35 years

60   (combined 90)

age 55 with 3% reduction per year less than 90, or age 60, whichever is less, deferred 5%

No limit, but cannot contribute if collecting pension. Other options available.

AB

5 years

Unlimited after 1991

65 and combined 85

2% per point short of 85 index  or per year short of age 65, whichever is lesser

Up to 60%/year, but cannot contribute once retired.

SK

old plan

1 year

35 years

65; Combined 85 or
60+20 or
30 years eligible service (no age requirement); part-time 65; counted

age 55 with 20 eligible year (reduction of .25%/month prior to age 60)

No limit, but cannot contribute.

SK

new plan


1 year

Unlimited after 1991
Combined 85 or
60+20 or
30 years eligible service (no age requirement).

Part-time counted
55 with 1 eligible year (reduction of .25%/month prior to age 65)
No limit, but cannot contribute.

MB

2 years
if less than 10 years, benefit is reduced re service before 1985

Unlimited 70% of salary limit to pension

Age 55 with 10 (where age + service = 80)

age 55 with 10 eligible years Bridging benefit provided equal in value to reduction.

Up to 120 days under contract

ON

2 years

Unlimited after 1991

65; combined 85 (no age requirement)

age 50 with 2.5% penalty short of 85 points.

First 3 years, up to 95 days, thereafter, up to 20 days.

QC

(RREGOP)

2 years

35 years

60   ( 35 years of service)

age 55,  2 years service, 4% penalty per year

If plan member prior to 1983, no restrictions. Penalty thereafter.

NB

5 years

35 years

65 Combined 87 or 35 years service  (no age requirement)

Combined 80 or 60 with 5% penalty per year

Up to 80 days/yr of supply teaching with Dep. Minister approval.

NS

2 years

35 years

65, Age 55 and combined 85 or 35 years service (no age requirement)
or  60 with 10 years.

55 with 20, 50 with 30, 5% penalty per yr that age less than 55 or service less than 35, whichever is lesser

69.5 days/year

PE

5 years

Unlimited

60,  Age 55 with 30  or
35 yrs service (no age requirement)

reduced 1/4% per month for ages 55-60 without 30 years service or under 60 years.

No supply teaching restrictions;
pension suspended if on contract

NL

5 years

Unlimited to age 60; maximum 30 if partly acquired after 60.

60  

55 with 25 or

30 worked years (no age requirement)

29 worked years + 1 study year (no age requirement)

65 days/year and/or up to 19 consecutive days.

A maximum 1 year contract with ministerial approval.

B. Indexing Across the Provinces

Prov

Current Benefits Indexed

Deferred benefits Indexed

Rate of Indexing

Funding

BC

All

Yes

Up to CPI, provided funding is available in the IAA (Inflation Adjustment Account)

Separate fund made up of EE contributions of 2%, ER contributions of 1.13% minus cost of health benefits, and excess interest earnings

AB

All

Yes

Service before 1993 - 60% of AB CPI; after 1992 = 70% of AB CPI

No separate fund

SK old

All

No

80% of CPI

No separate fund


SK new

All

No
Automatic: Lesser of 3% and 80% of CPI.
AdHoc: At S.T. Federation discretion provided not exceeding 80% of CPI.

No separate fund.

MB

All

Yes

Based on CPI, amount but limited to ability of separate adjustment account to pay

Half COLA cost funded by separate PAA (pension adjustment account) to which 16.5% of gross teacher contributions directed. Province funds other half. Survivor receives 2/3 of adjustment.

ON

All

Yes

CPI to 8% with carry forward of excess

Integrated with main plan

QC
(RREGOP)

All

Yes

Current: Before Jul 1,1982:  CPI-3% After Jan 1, 2000: better of CPI - 3% or 50% of CPI
Full CPI during deferment of benefits.

No separate fund

NB

All

Yes

CPI to 4.75%

No separate fund

NS

All

No

CPI less 1%before Aug1/2006. After Jul31/2006, tied to Plan's funded status: below 90%=0, 90-99%=50%of CPI, 100%+=full CPI.

No separate fund

PE

All

Yes

60% of CPI to max of 4%

No separate fund

NL

All (if integrated with CPP and age 65)

Yes

60% of CPI to max 1.2% (limited to ability of separate fund to pay)

1.7% of salary and allowances put in separate indexing account (IA).

C. Qualifying Service Across the Provinces

Prov

Military

Private School

Leave of Absence

Unpaid Study Leave

Unpaid Sick Leave

Time on LTD

Public Office

Part-time service

Child Rearing

BC

No

No

If purchased
within 5 years

Yes, if purchased by Mar 31, 2007

Yes, if purchased

Yes

Yes, if purchased
17 weeks maternity/35 weeks parental.

Yes, if purchased

5 years eligibility
service only

AB
 

No

Yes, if school operated by ATRF Board

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes
auto accrual after 1992

No

No

Yes

SK

old plan

No

7 years

50% paid

1 year, if purchased

No

Yes

Qualifying service

Yes

Up to CCRA max after Feb 1998.

SK new plan
No

7 years

50% paid
1 year, if purchased No Time after July 1, 1993 counted Qualifying service
Yes
Parenting absence up to CCRA max.

MB

Yes

No

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

ON

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

10 days min req'd

Can be purchased

QC
(RREGOP)

Yes (very restricted)

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes, if on leave of absence

Yes (if on leave of absence)

Yes
MLA only

Yes to 3 years

No

NB

Yes
WWI, II, Korea only

No

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes, (2 yrs under unpaid sick leave)

Yes, MLA only

Limited to 5 years before retirement

No

NS

Yes, for pre-1999 service

No

Yes, 2 years

Yes @ 50%

Yes @ 50%

Yes @ 50%

Yes, if on leave of absence

Yes

Up to 175 days per child

PE

Yes,
with restrictions

No

Yes

Yes

Yes